Sunday, 24 November 2013

A Cambridge Rider's Perspective on London Cycling.

I've just spent 24 hours of my weekend travelling around London by tube, bus, bicycle and on foot, but a few hours was by bicycle. Normally I ride commute in to, out of and around Cambridge, one of the UK's most cycled cities.  How does London stack up?

Every rider is different. Cards on the table ... I ride a lot and I can go fast, commuting on a touring bike, but I can also be found on a road bike, mountain bike, and motorcycle. I also spent a few years commuting in London in the 90's prior to the congestion charge. So this is the first time I've ridden London's roads in two decades.

We used Boris Bikes (TfL Barclays Cycle Hire). You can hire on the street without pre-registering and its cheap - can be as little as £2 for 24 hours if you complete each journey within 30 minutes. If you have an Oyster Card, the tube costs from £2.10 for a single journey capped from £7 per day;  buses costs are £1.40 a journey, capped at £4.40 per day.  It took us a while to get the bikes for the first time, just yank really hard after the green light.

Getting around

I've driven in London and know the roads are a dog-eat-dog kind of place so I tried to take us on quiet routes. If you visit the OpenCycleMap layer of OpenStreetMap you'll think you've hit the jackpot.


Central London has loads of quieter cycle routes. The local cycle routes are marked with a darker blue on OpenCycleMap.  But, just like Cambridge they are hard to follow and can be indirect meandering with many left and right turns.  I was armed with a Garmin GPS and a phone with OpenCycleMap and I was struggling. I'm not quite sure what the typical Boris bike user does.  

I also noticed some aspects of filtered permeability, i.e. no though routes for motor vehicles but bicycles and walkers can get through.  It works really well for short local journeys, keeping us well away from fast traffic. 

If I had one tip for London.  Get these local cycle networks really well signed. If you want to splash paint about, this could actually help.

Longer distance

Even following local cycle routes we found ourselves following major roads and crossing them.  I'm used to riding in Cambridge traffic but found the London drivers way more assertive. This is ok when driving, it seems to work, but on a bicycle I found myself unable to merge with traffic as easily as normal.  Part of the problem is that I was riding a slow upright bike. Merge into traffic with such as speed difference is like a leap of faith.  We quickly found ourselves making right turns not by crossing multiple lanes of traffic, but dismounting on the left and using pedestrian crossings. Safe but slow. It felt like a poor man's Dutch junction.  No wonder most commuters are males on fast bikes.

Thankfully I didn't have to cycle the CS2, but did see it from a bus on a Sunday.  I've seen it described as just paint and giving a false sense of security.  From the top-deck I could see there were so many parked cars in the bus and cycle lanes on a Sunday and that any rider would find themselves merging into traffic constantly causing conflict. 

We also passed a yellow Police sign asking for witnesses to a cyclist fatality I read about on the web, and realised we were not too far from Bow roundabout where there has been a three fatalities now. Pictures of CS2 can be viewed at Cyclists in the City.

The nearest you'll get to London's cycling environment in Cambridge are the dual carriageway sections of the ring road and Elizabeth Way, the bus lanes on Newmarket Road, and Queens Road for all its parked cars. Often in Cambridge there is a cycle path somewhere nearby. Traffic in Cambridge is far more easily controlled and rarely comes as close - when riding fast at least.

That day I found myself having to move out around parked cars to merge with fast approaching coaches on Grays Inn Road. I also watched a taxi drive very close behind my partner off the lights after we waited in an advanced stop box.

The worst mistake I made was at a traffic lit T junction near Limehouse (pictured below). The lights went amber as I crossed the line and I continued. Before I'd even made it to the first traffic lane I heard engines roar. There could have only been a precious second or two between light phases for vehicles to clear the junction - designed for vehicles at 30mph. Time limited for traffic flow over safety.


Conclusion

Would I cycle in London again?  On the local cycle routes, yes without a doubt.  Would I as a commuter?  I wouldn't want to on the more main routes, but faced with packed public transport, and as an experienced, committed and fast cyclist I would reluctantly learn how to survive. It's not for normal people.

7 comments:

  1. "It's not for normal people". Precisely. Until it is for normal people, cycling will remain a minority pursuit in the capital (and everywhere else that this is true).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was born and brought up in London but never allowed to cycle as a child in the 1950s and 60s. My parents thought it too dangerous. For nearlya decade I worked part time in Westminster and cycled a lot in areas I knew well from my youth. I rode my own bike, not a Boris one. They look very heavy and slow by comparison. London's greatest strength is back streets between main roads which Cambridge just doesn't have in large areas. I sometimes cycled from Putney to Westminster. It took a bit of experimentation to find better routes but the one I eventually settled on was mostly not signposted. It actually abandoned CS8 after a short stretch near Wandsworth Bridge for a much better river-front path in Battersea

    ReplyDelete
  3. I rode in London for in September. I was going from Kings Cross to Wandsworth, about 10 miles.

    Prior to the ride, I planned my route and printed out maps (prefer to satnav!). I used Cyclestreets (so connected with OSM and OCM) and avoided Google Maps (the Sustrans Beta) like the plague as it came up with truely awful routing.

    I found the central London routes along a lot of quiet roads and little cut-throughs very pleasant. I thought the signposting was a lot, lot better than Cambridge, although there was the odd missing sign which my maps helped me with!

    Crossing the river and through Elephant and Castle was pretty unpleasant, but I was quickly onto quiet roads again. Then, the main cycle route down to Wandsworth (NCN3?) was great. Hardly any traffic, nice and straight, just a joy compared to "busy" London.

    The route crossed Clapham and Wandsworth Common where I was nearly naughty. Show a green space to a Cambridge cyclist and you think you've got free reign! Not so in London, the cycle paths are strictly limited and you can't just go anywhere. Still very pleasant though!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I cycle in Cambridge and London daily as live in the former and work in the latter. The biggest difference between the two from my perspective is the sheer weight of traffic on main roads. Counter intuitively I generally feel safer on main roads in London than the equivalent in Cambridge as the average speeds tend to be lower as a result of all that traffic and the behaviour of drivers also seems be more predictable, but I then also ride differently in the two places. Infrastructure-wise I'd say they are both equally miserable, but there is more opportunity to sit up and take in your surroundings in Cambridge generally. The parks in both are wonderful places to cycle, though they are generally better lit in London. The biggest difference is the type of cyclists you encounter. Most of the people I cycle alongside in London are dinosaur males like me on fast bikes, but anecdotally at least, Cambridge has more student types and sit and and beg riders, though that may partly be because they are all concentrated on a very small number of routes rather than diffused across a big city like London.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Where allowed, it's enjoyable to cycle in London parks, however, I'm surprised that anybody holds up Cambridge parks as pleasant places to cross. The paths are narrow, heavily cambered, unmaintained and generally reluctantly/not recognised by pedestrians as dual use.
    To me, it's just another example of the lazy, sloppy attitude of the city and county councillors, who think they've achieved something by erecting an occasional sign.
    The majority of people who cycle do so despite the lack of infrastructure, not because of it. Six decades of neglect have created a class of cyclist, able to match the aggression of motorists and bloody-minded. Something that politicians of all colours should be ashamed of.

    ReplyDelete
  6. catering equipment hire http://www.birminghamcateringhire.com/ catering equipment hire

    Take advantage of our delivery and collection service, saving you time, effort and money.
    Let us turn your dream into a reality. From marquee's to marching bands, and everything in between.
    The last thing you want to do after a big night is a pile of washing up. Don’t worry, we’ll do it for you

    ReplyDelete
  7. Birmingham Catering Hire are pleased to announce the launch of their new website at www.birminghamcateringhire.com. After six months of development, and countless cups of coffee, the new website is finally live. This new site builds on the industry leading original site with the aim of an improved customer experience, better layout and increased functionality. Since its launch in 2011 Birmingham Catering Hire quickly established itself as the UK's leading online only catering and event hire store. As well as an improved website the new store also comes with an increased product range a whole new category in our specialized Exhibition Hire section, along with approximately 150 new products.
    New features and functionality is constantly being added. Soon you'll be able to amend your order online within 48 hours of your event, credit account facilities and also the ability to pay for your order in installments.
    To celebrate the launch we are offering 10% off all orders during March. Simply enter the code 'New Website' into your shopping cart for an immediate discount.

    ReplyDelete